Youky Design
menu

Jetpacks' SwitchPreferenceCompat vs Old-school SwitchPreference

Published on:

Jetpacks' SwitchPreferenceCompat vs Old-school SwitchPreferencethumbnail

SwitchPreferenceCompat and SwitchPreference are both UI components used in Android’s preference framework to provide a switch (on/off toggle) in settings screens. The key difference lies in their origin and compatibility:

  • SwitchPreference: This is the original implementation of a switch preference. It’s part of the older Android framework’s preference classes.

  • SwitchPreferenceCompat: This is the version from the AndroidX Preference Library. The “Compat” suffix signifies that it’s designed for broader compatibility across different Android versions. It’s part of the Jetpack suite of libraries, which are the recommended way to build modern Android apps.

Why SwitchPreferenceCompat is Preferred:

  1. AndroidX and Jetpack: SwitchPreferenceCompat aligns with modern Android development practices that emphasize using AndroidX libraries. These libraries provide backward compatibility, bug fixes, and consistent behavior across a wider range of Android OS versions.
  2. Consistency: Using AndroidX components like SwitchPreferenceCompat helps ensure a more consistent look and feel for your app’s settings across various devices and Android versions.
  3. Lifecycle Awareness and other Jetpack features: AndroidX components are often better integrated with other Jetpack libraries, like Lifecycle-aware components.
  4. Future-Proofing: Google is actively developing and maintaining the AndroidX libraries, making them the more future-proof choice.

Summary

You should generally prefer SwitchPreferenceCompat (and other *Compat preference classes from AndroidX) in your new Android projects. It offers better compatibility, aligns with modern development practices, and is the version that Google actively supports and recommends.

The underlying mechanism for saving the preference value, which is often SharedPreferences by default, is the same for both. The difference is primarily in the UI component class itself and the library it belongs to.

In your provided code from SettingsActivity.kt, you are correctly using SwitchPreferenceCompat, which is the recommended approach.

External Reference